• Banana Pudding
  • Banana Pudding
  • Banana Pudding

Banana Pudding

Your favorite Southern dessert gets an ice cream sammie makeover that will have you grinning down to the last crumb. Our chef-crafted, premium super-creamy banana pudding ice cream uses real bananas and vanilla for the perfect nostalgic twist on a classic.

The dreamy ice cream is sandwiched between two of our signature chewy golden-crusted brown sugar cookies for the perfect nod to the vanilla wafers you find in classic banana pudding. Hold the spoon, our take on banana pudding is finger food. 

Made in a certified nut-free facility. (Free of peanuts and tree nuts.)

Ingredients & Nutritional Label

Ice cream mix (milk, cream, liquid sugar [sugar, water], nonfat milk, locust bean gum, guar gum, carrageenan), brown sugar, enriched flour (wheat flour, niacin, reduced iron, thiamine mononitrate, riboflavin, folic acid), bananas, palm and soybean oil, honey, eggs, stabilizer (glucose syrup solids, guar gum, sorbitol, sugar, nonfat dry milk, palm kernel oil, xanthan gum, milk protein), salt, natural vanilla flavor, baking soda, lemon juice, baking powder (sodium acid pyrophosphate, sodium bicarbonate, corn starch, monocalcium phosphate) 

CONTAINS:  Milk, wheat, eggs, soy 

 

  • Certified Nut-Free
  • Woman Veteran Owned
  • No Artificial Colors
  • Non-GMO Sourced Ingredients

Size

Handcrafted Down to the Crumbs

Inspired by making people smile, we have one simple goal: to spread joy and eat ice cream

6

Vector
  • 5 stars: 15 (68%)
  • 4 stars: 3 (14%)
  • 3 stars: 1 (5%)
  • 2 stars: 1 (5%)
  • 1 star: 2 (9%)
Some of the reviews shown are from related products the merchant grouped with this one.
T
Theresa

The best. I love this 1.

S
Stefanie

So delicious

J
Jason

It's delicious!

A
Anonymous
It was good

It was good, but for me, just not as good as the key lime pie.

R
R. Brown
Mama’s nana pudding!

Tastes just like the banana pudding mama used to make.

M
Marcella

Not what I expected, not enough banana flavor.

s
s.c.

I like Blackout better but this is a good alternative as a break.

N
Niki
True to flavor

Great flavor! So yummy

J
Jason Cole
Absolutely delicious flavor and quality

I have been suckered many times by slick fb advertisements for new products. This one lives up to the ad. Absolutely delicious and big portions. Definitely a sharing size. I've ordered 2 more times already!

R
Rebecca
The best Ice cream sandwich

I'm so glad I went to fries in search of good.Ice cream behold I found it! I didn't even know about this this brand the first bite so delicious. Cookie) Software yet crisp and perfect sweetness the the premium banana pudding ice cream. Creamy perfect consistency and the perfect sweetness. I am hooked for life. Thank you for coming up with this remarkable concoction.

A
Anonymous
I love the banana pudding and the chomp size is

I love the banana pudding and the chomp size is perfect for one person!

J
Juli Baughman
Bland

Bland

A
Anonymous
Banana Pudding

My favorite Nightingale ice cream is the chocolate blackout. But I tried banana pudding in my last order and it was quite good. You did get the taste of banana pudding which I happen to love but rarely make anymore. It might be my second favorite flavor.

C
Carol
Fresh banana taste

Fresh banana taste, wonderful creamy ice cream with a wonderful sandwich cookie too!

K
Karen
Another hit flavor from Nightingale!

Delicious. Highly recommended. Now at the top of my favorites list.

B
BRANDIS
It was

It was ok

R
Robin
Wonderful flavor

Wonderful flavor from cookie and ice cream.

M
Melissa
Best!

First of all, there is not one bad flavor!! They just keep getting better and better! I am a banana fan, this is outstanding.

M
Monica

These are not worth the price! What a waste! Ice cream is not even good!

R
Rhonda

Best in class

B
Barbara

Delicious, but pricey.

R
Rachael

These were double the price of the product in store, but when no stores around offer the product it’s worth it! This is my favorite dessert by far!!