• Key Lime Pie
  • The Bakery Box - Don't Use
  • Key Lime Pie

Key Lime Pie

Unwrap the beach with our take on this iconic dessert. We swap key lime pie’s buttery graham cracker crust with two of our buttery golden-crusted brown sugar cookies sandwiched around creamy and tart key lime ice cream.

Our premium, small-batch ice cream is blended with key lime juice from the Florida Keys for a tangy and sweet twist on the beloved pie. Transport yourself to a beachfront getaway but for this treat…. No shirt? No shoes? No problem.

Made in a certified nut-free facility. (Free of peanuts and tree nuts.)

Ingredients & Nutritional Label

Ice cream mix (milk, cream, liquid sugar [sugar, water], nonfat milk, locust bean gum, guar gum, carrageenan), brown sugar, enriched flour (wheat flour, niacin, reduced iron, thiamine mononitrate, riboflavin, folic acid), palm and soybean oil, Key West lime juice from concentrate (filtered water, lime juice concentrates, lime oil), sweetened condensed milk (milk solids, sugar), eggs, stabilizer (glucose syrup solids, guar gum, sorbitol, sugar, nonfat dry milk, palm kernel oil, xanthan gum, milk protein), salt, baking soda.

CONTAINS:  Milk, wheat, eggs, soy.

 

  • Certified Nut-Free
  • Woman Veteran Owned
  • No Artificial Colors
  • Non-GMO Sourced Ingredients

Size

Handcrafted Down to the Crumbs

Inspired by making people smile, we have one simple goal: to spread joy and eat ice cream

6

Vector
  • 5 stars: 15 (88%)
  • 4 stars: 1 (6%)
  • 3 stars: 0 (0%)
  • 2 stars: 1 (6%)
  • 1 star: 0 (0%)
J
Jason

Very unique flavor.

K
Karla Otero
My favorite flavor

My favorite flavor, I love the tartness with the sweetness of the cookie base

A
Anonymous
They were really good

They were really good.

R
Ruth Ann Frederick
This one is my absolute

This one is my absolute favorite!

J
Jason Cole
I've ordered 3 times and have loved every flavor

I've ordered 3 times and have tried every flavor. They don't have or make a bad one everything is excellent!

A
Anonymous
Key lime is SUBLIME. All others awful

After trying all non-chocolately flavors, I was extremely unimpressed by all EXCEPT key lime. That one is a 10/10. The others 0 to 6 of I'm honest. I'm unsure how the quality could vary this much. Thoroughly disappointed as a whole. I hate that they take like 25 mins to get to a reasonable ice cream texture for biting & enjoying. Must be a weird artificial ingredient (gum guar?) slowing the process.

A
Anonymous
The best ice cream sandwich ever created! The key lime pie is as authentic as it comes

The best ice cream sandwich ever created! The key lime pie is as authentic as it comes. Perfect!

F
Felipe Herrera
Love it!

We bought 10 different flavors and Key lime pie was the top for my daughter and I. (My wife prefers the Brokie one)

J
JANET BLISS
key lime pie flavor a family favorite

Outstanding flavor! In fact, a family favorite. But, of course, we love every ice cream sandwich we’ve tried from your delicious array of options. Incredible!

A
Anonymous
Really delicious and refreshing sweet

Really delicious and refreshing sweet snack

V
Vicki
Delicious lime flavor

Delicious lime flavor. The cookie was also delicious!!!

J
Jessica
Showed up melted when it arrived to my

Showed up melted when it arrived to my home

A
Anonymous
A+

A+, as are all the flavors!

R
Rhonda

Best in class

M
Michael

Fantastic product

B
Barbara

Delicious, but pricey.

R
Rachael

These were double the price of the product in store, but when no stores around offer the product it’s worth it! This is my favorite dessert by far!!